Cambridge International AS & A Level Chemistry 9701 · A Level topic 30
Hydrocarbons (A Level)
What this chapter covers30.1
Benzene rings are everywhere in useful chemicals: in drugs such as paracetamol and procaine, in dyes, in explosives, in the monomers of polystyrene and Kevlar. Almost all of them are made by attaching new groups to a benzene ring, or by modifying a group already attached. This chapter covers the reactions that do it.
The previous chapter explained why the benzene ring is unusually stable: its six π electrons are delocalised, and the ring is 152 kJ mol−1 more stable than a structure with three separate C=C bonds would be. That stability controls everything here. Benzene does not react like an alkene: it needs a powerful, positively charged electrophile, usually generated with a catalyst, and it reacts by substitution, so that the delocalised ring survives. The chapter covers five such substitutions, then two reactions that do not keep the ring intact or do not touch it at all — hydrogenation of the ring and oxidation of a side chain — and finally the rules that decide where on the ring a second group goes.
What topic 30 asks you to do
30.1 Arenes — describe the chemistry of arenes as shown by benzene and methylbenzene: (a) substitution with Cl2 or Br2 and an AlCl3 or AlBr3 catalyst to form halogenoarenes; (b) nitration with concentrated HNO3 and concentrated H2SO4 between 25 °C and 60 °C; (c) Friedel–Crafts alkylation by CH3Cl and AlCl3 and heat; (d) Friedel–Crafts acylation by CH3COCl and AlCl3 and heat; (e) complete oxidation of the side chain with hot alkaline KMnO4 and then dilute acid to give a benzoic acid; (f) hydrogenation of the ring with H2 and a Pt or Ni catalyst and heat to give a cyclohexane ring.
Describe the mechanism of electrophilic substitution, exemplified by the formation of nitrobenzene and bromobenzene, and explain in terms of delocalisation why substitution predominates over addition. Predict whether halogenation occurs in the side chain or in the ring, depending on the conditions. Describe how different substituents direct to different ring positions (limited to –NH2, –OH, –R, –NO2, –COOH and –COR).
What you are assumed to know already
- The bonding in benzene: sp² carbons, a planar ring and a delocalised π system; the evidence against the Kekulé structure (topic 29.3).
- The terms electrophile and electrophilic substitution; curly-arrow conventions (topics 13.2 and 29.2).
- Electrophilic addition to alkenes and the stability order of carbocations (topic 14.2).
- Free-radical substitution of alkanes in UV light: initiation, propagation and termination (topic 14.1).
- Naming substituted benzenes (topic 29.1).
Benzene, methylbenzene and their reactions30.1.1
Benzene, C6H6, and methylbenzene, C6H5CH3 (toluene), are colourless liquids that do not mix with water. Both burn with a very smoky flame, because the proportion of carbon in the molecule is high and combustion in air is incomplete. Methylbenzene is the syllabus example of an alkylbenzene: it has a benzene ring and a saturated side chain, and so it can react in two separate places — at the ring, like benzene, or at the CH3 group, like an alkane.
All the reactions in this chapter are summarised in Figure 30.1. Five of them are electrophilic substitutions of a ring hydrogen. The other two are different in kind: hydrogenation adds hydrogen across the ring and destroys the aromatic system, and oxidation with potassium manganate(VII) attacks the side chain and leaves the ring untouched.
Reagents and conditions must be complete
Marks for reagents and conditions are lost for single missing words. "Concentrated" is needed for both acids in nitration; AlCl3 must not be written as an aqueous solution, because water hydrolyses it; "Friedel–Crafts" alone does not name a reaction — it is Friedel–Crafts alkylation or acylation; the KMnO4 oxidation needs heat and is followed by acidification.
Nitration30.1.1(b), 30.1.2(a)
When benzene is warmed with a mixture of concentrated nitric acid and concentrated sulfuric acid, a pale yellow oil, nitrobenzene, is formed. A hydrogen atom on the ring has been replaced by a nitro group, –NO2:
The electrophile: the nitronium ion
Nitric acid on its own does not nitrate benzene at a useful rate. Sulfuric acid is the stronger acid of the two, and in the mixture it protonates nitric acid, which then loses water to give the nitronium ion, NO2+. The overall equation for its formation is usually written:
A simpler version, HNO3 + H2SO4 → NO2+ + H2O + HSO4−, is also correct. NO2+ carries a full positive charge and is a powerful electrophile — powerful enough to attack the delocalised π system of benzene.
The mechanism
The reaction takes place in two steps (Figure 30.2).
- Attack. Two electrons from the delocalised π system form a new bond to the nitrogen atom of NO2+. The curly arrow starts inside the ring — at the π electrons — and ends at the N atom. The carbon that is attacked now has four σ bonds (to two ring carbons, to H and to NO2) and becomes sp³. The ring has lost two of its six π electrons: the remaining four are delocalised over the other five carbon atoms, which share the positive charge. This intermediate is drawn as a horseshoe — a partial circle open at the sp³ carbon — with a + inside it.
- Loss of H+. The C–H bond on the sp³ carbon breaks heterolytically. Its two electrons move back into the ring, restoring the complete delocalised π system, and H+ is released. The curly arrow starts on the C–H bond and ends inside the ring.
The H+ released combines with a hydrogensulfate ion, H+ + HSO4− → H2SO4, so the sulfuric acid is regenerated: it is a catalyst.
Why the temperature matters
The syllabus gives the temperature as between 25 °C and 60 °C. Above about 60 °C a second nitro group substitutes, giving mainly 1,3-dinitrobenzene, so the temperature is kept low to obtain the mononitro product. Methylbenzene reacts faster than benzene because the methyl group releases electron density into the ring (section 10), and it gives a mixture of 2-nitromethylbenzene and 4-nitromethylbenzene.
Why the product is useful
Nitrobenzene is reduced by heating with tin and concentrated hydrochloric acid, followed by sodium hydroxide, to phenylamine, C6H5NH2 — the starting point for azo dyes (chapter on nitrogen compounds). Nitration followed by reduction is the standard way of putting an –NH2 group on a benzene ring.
Halogenation of the ring30.1.1(a), 30.1.2(a)
Benzene does not react with bromine water or with bromine in the dark: the Br2 molecule, with no permanent dipole, is not a strong enough electrophile. In the presence of a halogen carrier — anhydrous aluminium bromide, AlBr3, or iron(III) bromide, FeBr3 — bromine reacts at room temperature, the red-brown colour fades, and misty fumes of hydrogen bromide are given off:
Chlorine reacts in the same way with AlCl3 or FeCl3 to give chlorobenzene. The products are halogenoarenes (aryl halides), the subject of the next chapter.
How the halogen carrier works
Aluminium in AlBr3 has only six electrons in its outer shell and can accept a lone pair. It accepts one from a bromine molecule, which polarises and then breaks the Br–Br bond heterolytically, releasing an electrophile that behaves as Br+:
The mechanism is then identical to nitration: attack on Br+ by the π electrons, a positive intermediate, and loss of H+. The H+ reacts with AlBr4− to regenerate the catalyst and form HBr (Figure 30.3).
Keep the catalyst dry
AlCl3 and AlBr3 react vigorously with water and are destroyed by it, so the reaction is carried out with dry reagents. Writing "Cl2(aq) and AlCl3" in an answer is not credited. Writing Cl− or Br− as the electrophile is also a common error: an electrophile accepts electrons, so it cannot be a negative ion.
Friedel–Crafts alkylation and acylation30.1.1(c)(d)
The same kind of catalyst can generate a carbon electrophile, which forms a new C–C bond to the ring. These are the Friedel–Crafts reactions, the most important way of attaching a carbon chain to a benzene ring.
Alkylation
Benzene heated with a chloroalkane and AlCl3 gives an alkylbenzene. With chloromethane the product is methylbenzene:
AlCl3 accepts a lone pair from the chlorine of the chloroalkane and removes it as AlCl4−, leaving a carbocation — the electrophile:
Other halogenoalkanes work in the same way: chloroethane gives ethylbenzene and 2-chloropropane gives (1-methylethyl)benzene, known as cumene. An alkyl group releases electrons into the ring, so the product is more reactive than benzene and can be alkylated again; an excess of benzene is used to limit this.
Acylation
With an acyl chloride instead of a chloroalkane, the electrophile is an acylium ion, RCO+, and the product is an aromatic ketone. Ethanoyl chloride gives phenylethanone:
In the mechanism the ring attacks the carbon atom of the acylium ion, which carries the positive charge. The –COCH3 group withdraws electrons from the ring, so the product is less reactive than benzene and a second acylation does not occur (Figure 30.4).
Worked example 30.1 · Identifying a Friedel–Crafts reagent
| Problem | Benzene reacts with compound D, with a catalyst, to give cumene, C6H5CH(CH3)2, and an inorganic product E. Identify D, E and the catalyst. |
| Reasoning | A C–C bond has formed between the ring and the middle carbon of a propyl group, so the electrophile must be (CH3)2CH+. That carbocation comes from a chloroalkane with Cl on the middle carbon. |
| Answer | D = 2-chloropropane, CH3CHClCH3; E = HCl; catalyst AlCl3 (anhydrous). The reaction is Friedel–Crafts alkylation. |
| Check | 1-chloropropane would put the ring on the end carbon; atom count C6H6 + C3H7Cl → C9H12 + HCl balances. |
Quick check 30.1
- Give the reagents and conditions for making nitrobenzene from benzene.
answer
Concentrated nitric acid and concentrated sulfuric acid, at a temperature between 25 °C and 60 °C. - Write an equation for the formation of the electrophile in the chlorination of benzene.
answer
Cl2 + AlCl3 → Cl+ + AlCl4− - Show how AlCl3 is regenerated in a Friedel–Crafts reaction.
answer
H+ + AlCl4− → AlCl3 + HCl - Name the organic product of benzene with ethanoyl chloride and AlCl3, and the type of reaction.
answer
Phenylethanone, C6H5COCH3; Friedel–Crafts acylation (electrophilic substitution). - Why is nitration kept below 60 °C?
answer
At higher temperatures further nitration occurs, giving dinitro compounds.
Drawing the mechanism correctly30.1.2(a)(b)
Every electrophilic substitution in this chapter follows the same pattern, whatever the electrophile E+. It is worth learning as a single mechanism with a variable part, and it is examined as one: the syllabus names nitration and bromination as the examples, but questions regularly ask for the mechanism with an electrophile you have not seen, such as Cl–C+=O or a chlorine atom attacking pyridine.
The electron-rich and electron-poor partners
The ring's delocalised π system is the source of electrons. The electrophile has a vacant orbital or a positive charge on one particular atom — N in NO2+, C in CH3+ and CH3CO+, the halogen in Cl+ and Br+ — and that atom is the one that forms the new bond.
Step 1: formation of the intermediate
- Arrow 1 starts inside the hexagon, at the delocalised π electrons, and ends at the electron-deficient atom of E+. It does not start at a carbon atom or at a corner of the hexagon.
- Bond formed: a new C–E σ bond, using two electrons from the π system.
- Intermediate: the attacked carbon is now sp³ and carries both H and E. The remaining four π electrons are delocalised over the other five carbons. Draw the partial ring as a horseshoe that does not pass through the sp³ carbon, and put the + inside the horseshoe — not on the sp³ carbon and not on E.
Step 2: loss of H+
- Arrow 2 starts on the C–H bond of the sp³ carbon (not on the H atom) and ends inside the ring.
- Bond broken: C–H, heterolytically; both electrons return to the ring, which regains its six delocalised π electrons.
- Products: the substituted arene and H+. Always show the H+; if the question asks, show it combining with HSO4− or AlX4− to regenerate the catalyst.
The errors that lose marks in this mechanism
- The first arrow drawn from a corner of the hexagon, or going to the wrong atom of the electrophile (to O instead of N in NO2+, to O instead of C in an acylium ion).
- The horseshoe drawn through the sp³ carbon, or a complete circle kept in the intermediate.
- The + charge placed on the sp³ carbon, on the H, or on the incoming group — or two + charges on one intermediate.
- The second arrow starting on the H atom instead of the C–H bond, or pointing outwards.
- H+ omitted from the products, or HCl shown leaving directly without a Cl− ever having been formed.
- A negative ion — Cl−, Br− — given as the electrophile.
Why substitution wins over addition30.1.2(b)
After step 1 the intermediate has a choice. It could complete an addition, as the carbocation in alkene chemistry does, by bonding to a negative ion. Or it could lose H+ and complete a substitution. With benzene, substitution happens every time. The reason is the delocalisation energy.
The addition product would be a cyclohexadiene: two localised C=C bonds and no delocalised ring. Forming it would throw away the stabilisation of about 150 kJ mol−1 that the aromatic ring provides. Losing H+, on the other hand, returns the two electrons of the C–H bond to the ring and restores the full delocalised π system. The substitution product keeps the aromatic stability; the addition product would not.
The same idea explains the energy profile of the reaction (Figure 30.5). Step 1 destroys the complete delocalisation, so it has a high activation energy and is the slow, rate-determining step; that is why a strong electrophile is needed at all. Step 2 restores the delocalisation and is fast, with a small activation energy.
Explaining "substitution rather than addition"
A complete explanation links three ideas: benzene has a delocalised π system which gives it extra stability; addition would destroy the delocalisation in the product; substitution (loss of H+) restores it. "Benzene is stable" on its own is not an explanation. The same argument explains why benzene does not decolourise bromine water and needs a halogen carrier.
Worked example 30.2 · The mechanism with an unfamiliar electrophile
| Problem | COCl2 reacts with AlCl3 to give AlCl4− and the electrophile Cl–C+=O. This substitutes into benzene to give C6H5COCl and H+. Suggest a mechanism. |
| Electron-poor atom | The positive charge is on carbon: the new bond will be ring C–C. |
| Arrow 1 | From inside the hexagon to the C of Cl–C+=O. |
| Intermediate | Horseshoe over five carbons with + inside; the sp³ carbon carries H and –COCl. |
| Arrow 2 | From the C–H bond into the ring; products C6H5COCl + H+. |
| Check | Only one + in the intermediate (none on –COCl); H+ shown; the ring carbon count is still six. |
A heterocyclic example
Pyridine, C5H5N, has the same delocalised six-electron π system as benzene (chapter 29), and it undergoes the same electrophilic substitution: with Cl2 and AlCl3 it gives 3-chloropyridine and HCl. The mechanism is drawn exactly as for benzene, with the horseshoe of the intermediate spread over the four carbons and the nitrogen that are not attacked. Only one positive charge is shown, inside the partial ring.
Examination questions on this part of the unit. Try each one on paper before opening the answer.
Answer and marking guidance
Answer and marking guidance
Part (c) of this question, on chlorobenzene and chloroethane, is in the chapter on halogen compounds.
Answer and marking guidance
This part follows 30A.1 in the same question: cumene is (1-methylethyl)benzene.
Answer and marking guidance
The pyridine structure is given in part (d) of the same question (29A.3).
Answer and marking guidance
Answer and marking guidance
Examiner's overall observation · The electrophilic substitution mechanism
Answered well: by candidates who had learned the mechanism; many clear, accurate intermediates were drawn, including for unfamiliar electrophiles and for pyridine. Equations generating Cl+, Br+ and carbocations with an aluminium halide were usually correct.
Recurring errors: curly arrows drawn carelessly — the first not starting inside the ring or not reaching the electrophilic atom, the second starting on the H rather than the C–H bond; the partly delocalised ring drawn through the sp³ carbon; the + charge placed on the sp³ carbon, or a second + placed on the incoming group; H+ left out of the products. Some did not use the space provided beside the starting arene to show the first attack.
Equations: errors in generating NO2+ included SO4−, NO2 or H3SO4+ as products and unbalanced charges; in halogenation a chloride ion was sometimes formed instead of Cl+.
Naming: electrophilic addition and nucleophilic substitution were the common wrong names for the mechanism.
Oxidising the side chain30.1.1(e)
The benzene ring is not oxidised by potassium manganate(VII), but an alkyl side chain attached to it is. When methylbenzene is heated under reflux with alkaline potassium manganate(VII), the purple colour fades and a brown precipitate of manganese(IV) oxide forms. The methyl group is oxidised to a carboxylate group, and acidifying the mixture with dilute acid then gives benzoic acid, which crystallises as the solution cools:
The oxidation is complete: it is the carbon atom joined to the ring that ends up as the –COOH carbon, and the rest of any longer side chain is lost. Ethylbenzene, propylbenzene and (1-methylethyl)benzene all give benzoic acid, not phenylethanoic acid or any longer acid. Each alkyl group on the ring is oxidised separately, so 1,3-dimethylbenzene gives benzene-1,3-dicarboxylic acid. Groups that are not alkyl — halogens, –NO2 — are unaffected: 1-methyl-4-nitrobenzene gives 4-nitrobenzoic acid.
The whole side chain goes
The commonest wrong product of side-chain oxidation is C6H5CH2COOH from ethylbenzene — oxidising only the end carbon, as with a primary alcohol. With KMnO4 and an alkylbenzene, the carbon attached to the ring becomes the carboxyl carbon, so the product is always a benzoic acid. In alkaline solution the product is first formed as its salt (C6H5COO−); the dilute acid is added to convert it to the acid.
Hydrogenation of the ring30.1.1(f)
Although benzene resists addition, it can be made to add hydrogen. Heated with hydrogen and a platinum or nickel catalyst, benzene is converted to cyclohexane, and methylbenzene to methylcyclohexane:
Three molecules of hydrogen add, one for each pair of π electrons. The conditions are harsher than those for hydrogenating an alkene, and the reaction goes all the way to the cyclohexane ring: once the first molecule of H2 has added, the delocalisation is lost and the remaining C=C bonds add hydrogen easily. This is the reaction whose enthalpy change, −208 kJ mol−1, was used in chapter 29 as evidence for the delocalisation energy of benzene. An alkyl side chain is unchanged: cumene gives (1-methylethyl)cyclohexane.
Halogenation: ring or side chain?30.1.3
Methylbenzene has hydrogen atoms in two very different places — on the ring and on the methyl group — and chlorine can replace either. Which one is replaced depends entirely on the conditions, because the conditions decide the mechanism (Figure 30.6).
- In the ring: chlorine with an AlCl3 (or FeCl3) halogen carrier, at room temperature and in the dark. The catalyst generates Cl+, which attacks the electron-rich ring by electrophilic substitution. The methyl group directs the chlorine to the 2- and 4-positions, giving 2-chloromethylbenzene and 4-chloromethylbenzene.
- In the side chain: chlorine in ultraviolet light (or sunlight, or at a high temperature), with no catalyst. UV light splits Cl2 homolytically into chlorine radicals, which substitute into the CH3 group by free-radical substitution, exactly as they do with an alkane. The first product is (chloromethyl)benzene, C6H5CH2Cl; with excess chlorine, further substitution gives C6H5CHCl2 and C6H5CCl3.
With a longer side chain there may be more than one side-chain product. (1-methylethyl)benzene, cumene, has two kinds of side-chain hydrogen — the single H on the carbon attached to the ring, and the six equivalent H atoms of the two methyl groups — so free-radical chlorination gives two monochloro products, C6H5CCl(CH3)2 and C6H5CH(CH3)CH2Cl. Putting the chlorine on "one methyl group or the other" does not give two different compounds: the two methyl groups are equivalent.
Quick check 30.2
- Give the organic product when ethylbenzene is heated with alkaline KMnO4 and the mixture is then acidified.
answer
Benzoic acid, C6H5COOH — the whole side chain is oxidised. - State the reagents and conditions to convert methylbenzene into methylcyclohexane.
answer
Hydrogen with a platinum or nickel catalyst, heated. - What conditions make chlorine substitute into the side chain of methylbenzene, and what is the mechanism?
answer
UV light (or heat), no catalyst; free-radical substitution. - Why do answers such as "Cl2(aq) + AlCl3" not score?
answer
Water hydrolyses (destroys) AlCl3; the halogen carrier must be anhydrous.
Examination questions on this part of the unit. Try each one on paper before opening the answer.
Answer and marking guidance
Part (a) of this question is 30B.1; part (b)(iv), on carbon-13 NMR, belongs to the analytical chapter.
Answer and marking guidance
Part (b)(iii), the equation for step 2, is in the chapter on acyl chlorides; part (b)(iv) is 30B.6.
Answer and marking guidance
Fig. 7.1 of this question, showing the whole procaine synthesis, is reproduced with 29A.4 in the previous chapter.
Answer and marking guidance
Directing effects30.1.4
When a benzene ring already carries one group, a second electrophile does not attack all the remaining positions equally. Some groups send it mainly to the positions next to them (2 and 6) and opposite them (4); others send it to the positions one further away (3 and 5). The syllabus limits the groups to six (Figure 30.7 and Table 30.1).
| group on the ring | effect on ring electron density | new group goes to | example |
|---|---|---|---|
| –NH2 (phenylamine) | donates (lone pair overlaps with the ring) | 2-, 4- and 6- | bromine water gives 2,4,6-tribromophenylamine |
| –OH (phenol) | donates (lone pair overlaps with the ring) | 2-, 4- and 6- | bromine water gives 2,4,6-tribromophenol |
| –R (alkyl, e.g. –CH3) | donates (positive inductive effect) | 2- and 4- | chlorination gives 2- and 4-chloromethylbenzene |
| –NO2 | withdraws | 3- | nitration of nitrobenzene gives 1,3-dinitrobenzene |
| –COOH | withdraws | 3- | nitration of benzoic acid gives 3-nitrobenzoic acid |
| –COR (e.g. –COCH3) | withdraws | 3- | nitration of phenylethanone gives the 3-nitro product |
The same electronic effect changes the rate. Groups that release electrons into the ring make it more attractive to electrophiles, so the ring reacts faster than benzene — dramatically so for phenol and phenylamine, which react with bromine water with no catalyst at all (the chapters on hydroxy compounds and nitrogen compounds). Groups that withdraw electrons make the ring react more slowly than benzene.
Why an alkyl group directs to the 2- and 4-positions
The directing effect can be traced to the stability of the positive intermediate. In the intermediate, the positive charge is spread over three of the five carbons of the horseshoe: those at the 2-, 4- and 6-positions relative to the carbon that was attacked. If the attack is at C2 or C4 of methylbenzene, one of those three carbons is C1 — the carbon carrying the methyl group. A positive charge on C1 is a tertiary carbocation, stabilised by electron donation from the attached alkyl group, so this intermediate is lower in energy and forms faster. If the attack is at C3, the charge never reaches C1 and every contributing carbocation is secondary (Figure 30.8).
Planning the order of steps
Directing effects decide the order in which groups must be introduced when two groups are needed on a ring. The rule is simple: the group already on the ring decides where the next one goes, so the first group must be the one that directs to the position required.
Worked example 30.3 · 4-nitrobenzoic acid or 3-nitrobenzoic acid?
| Target 1 | 4-nitrobenzoic acid from methylbenzene. |
| Reasoning | –NO2 must end up para to the carbon that becomes –COOH. The CH3 group directs to the 4-position; a –COOH group would direct to the 3-position. So nitrate first, while CH3 is still there. |
| Route | Step 1: conc. HNO3 + conc. H2SO4 → 4-nitromethylbenzene (separated from the 2-isomer). Step 2: hot alkaline KMnO4, then dilute acid → 4-nitrobenzoic acid. |
| Target 2 | 3-nitrobenzoic acid from methylbenzene. |
| Route | Oxidise first (KMnO4, then acid) to benzoic acid; then nitrate. The –COOH group directs the NO2 to the 3-position. |
| Check | Swapping the steps in either route gives the other isomer: the order is the whole point of the question. |
Worked example 30.4 · An amine para to an alkyl group
| Target | 4-(1-methylethyl)phenylamine from benzene in three steps. |
| Reasoning | The NH2 comes from reducing an NO2 group. The NO2 must go para to the alkyl group — so the alkyl group must already be on the ring when nitration happens, because an NO2 group would direct the alkyl group to the 3-position. |
| Route | Step 1: (CH3)2CHBr with AlBr3 or FeBr3 (Friedel–Crafts alkylation). Step 2: conc. HNO3 + conc. H2SO4, 25–60 °C. Step 3: Sn and conc. HCl, heat (then NaOH(aq)). |
| Common error | Nitrating first. Tin is a reactant in step 3, not a catalyst. |
Explaining a position of substitution with two groups present
When a ring carries two or more groups, give a reason for each group: for example, "the –OH group directs to the 2- and 4-positions, and both 2-positions are already occupied, so only its 4-position is free; each –COOH group directs to its 3-position, which is the same carbon". Half the marks are lost by describing only one group, and none are gained by discussing the incoming group, which has no directing effect of its own.
Quick check 30.3
- Which of –OH, –NO2, –CH3, –COOH direct an incoming electrophile to the 3-position?
answer
–NO2 and –COOH. - Predict the major products of nitrating methylbenzene.
answer
2-nitromethylbenzene and 4-nitromethylbenzene. - Benzoic acid is nitrated. Name the main product.
answer
3-nitrobenzoic acid. - Explain why the methyl group in methylbenzene makes the ring react faster with electrophiles than benzene does.
answer
The methyl group donates electron density to the ring (positive inductive effect), so the ring attracts electrophiles more strongly and the positive intermediate is stabilised. - In which order should you nitrate and oxidise methylbenzene to make 3-nitrobenzoic acid? Explain.
answer
Oxidise first, then nitrate: –COOH directs to the 3-position, whereas –CH3 would direct to the 2- and 4-positions.
Examination questions on this part of the unit. Try each one on paper before opening the answer.
Answer and marking guidance
Answer and marking guidance
Answer and marking guidance
Answer and marking guidance
Examiner's overall observation · Reactions of arenes and directing effects
Answered well: identifying Friedel–Crafts reagents and catalysts; the reagents for nitration, reduction with tin and hydrochloric acid, and hydrogenation; the use of alkaline KMnO4 to oxidise an aromatic side chain; conditions for chlorination in the ring and in the side chain.
Found difficult: the product of side-chain oxidation — C6H5CH2COOH was a common wrong answer for ethylbenzene, and the reduction of cumene was better known than its oxidation. Explaining directing effects in terms of the stability of the intermediate cations: many knew that methyl is electron-donating, but few went on to compare the carbocations. When two groups were present, about half the answers explained the effect of only one of them.
Recurring errors: "Friedel–Crafts" without "alkylation"; including water with the AlCl3 catalyst; 1-chloropropane instead of 2-chloropropane to make cumene; drawing the same side-chain product twice; describing tin as a catalyst; omitting "concentrated" with the acids; nitrating before alkylating when an NO2 group would then direct to the wrong position; missing one condition ("acidified or alkaline", "heat") for the KMnO4 oxidation.
What successful answers did: matched each reagent to its complete conditions, and used the directing effect of the group already on the ring to fix the order of the steps.
Reagents and conditions at a glance30.1
| reaction | reagents | conditions | electrophile or attacking species | product from benzene (or methylbenzene) | type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| nitration | conc. HNO3 + conc. H2SO4 | 25–60 °C | NO2+ | nitrobenzene (2- and 4-nitromethylbenzene) | electrophilic substitution |
| chlorination / bromination of the ring | Cl2 + AlCl3, or Br2 + AlBr3 | room temperature, anhydrous, dark | Cl+, Br+ | chlorobenzene, bromobenzene (2- and 4-chloromethylbenzene) | electrophilic substitution |
| Friedel–Crafts alkylation | CH3Cl + AlCl3 | heat | CH3+ | methylbenzene | electrophilic substitution |
| Friedel–Crafts acylation | CH3COCl + AlCl3 | heat | CH3CO+ | phenylethanone | electrophilic substitution |
| side-chain oxidation | alkaline KMnO4, then dilute acid | heat (reflux) | — | (from methylbenzene) benzoic acid | oxidation |
| hydrogenation | H2, Pt or Ni | heat | — | cyclohexane (methylcyclohexane) | addition (reduction) |
| side-chain halogenation | Cl2 or Br2 | UV light or heat, no catalyst | Cl• (radical) | (from methylbenzene) (chloromethyl)benzene | free-radical substitution |
Misconceptions and how the topic is assessed30.1
| misconception | why it is wrong | correct model | examination consequence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Benzene reacts with bromine like an alkene. | Addition would destroy the delocalised π system. | Substitution with a halogen carrier; the ring is restored by loss of H+. | Addition products and "decolourises bromine water" are wrong. |
| The electrophile in halogenation is Cl−. | An electrophile accepts electrons; a negative ion cannot. | Cl+ from Cl2 + AlCl3. | Equation and mechanism marks lost. |
| The + of the intermediate is on the carbon that was attacked. | That carbon is sp³ with four bonds; the charge is on the five carbons of the partial ring. | Horseshoe over five carbons, + inside it. | The intermediate mark is lost. |
| The second curly arrow starts from the H atom. | Curly arrows start at electrons — at a bond or a lone pair. | From the C–H bond into the ring. | The arrow mark is lost. |
| KMnO4 oxidises only the end carbon of a side chain. | The carbon joined to the ring is oxidised; the rest is lost. | Every alkylbenzene gives a benzoic acid. | C6H5CH2COOH from ethylbenzene is wrong. |
| Any chlorination of methylbenzene gives the same product. | The conditions select the mechanism. | AlCl3/dark → ring; UV → side chain. | Wrong conditions or products. |
| The incoming group decides where it goes. | Only the groups already on the ring direct. | –NH2, –OH, –R → 2,4; –NO2, –COOH, –COR → 3. | Wrong isomers and wrong order of steps. |
| Sn is a catalyst in reducing nitrobenzene. | Sn is oxidised; it is a reactant. | Sn + conc. HCl, heat, then NaOH(aq). | The description is not credited. |
| question family | typical demand | what the answer needs |
|---|---|---|
| Mechanism | complete the mechanism, show the intermediate, 2–4 marks | two arrows placed exactly; horseshoe + intermediate; H+; often with an unfamiliar electrophile or ring |
| Electrophile generation | write an equation, 1 mark | balanced for atoms and charge; the catalyst regenerated if asked |
| Reagents and conditions | state them for one step of a route | every word: concentrated, anhydrous, heat, UV, then acidify |
| Products | draw the product of a named reagent | benzoic acid from any side chain; cyclohexane ring from H2/Ni; 2- and 4- isomers |
| Ring or side chain | conditions and products for each | AlCl3, dark vs UV; distinct isomers only |
| Directing effects | explain a position; order the steps of a synthesis | a reason for every group on the ring; carbocation stability for alkyl groups |
| Explanation | why substitution, not addition | delocalisation, lost in addition, restored in substitution |
Self-test30.1
Twelve questions on the whole chapter. Each gives its reason once you answer.
Definitions to learn30.1
| term | definition |
|---|---|
| arene | a hydrocarbon containing one or more benzene rings |
| electrophilic substitution | a reaction in which an electrophile replaces an atom (usually H) on an aromatic ring, the delocalised ring being restored |
| halogen carrier | a catalyst such as AlCl3, AlBr3 or FeBr3 that accepts a lone pair from a halogen molecule and generates a positive halogen electrophile |
| nitronium ion | NO2+, the electrophile in nitration, formed from concentrated nitric and sulfuric acids |
| Friedel–Crafts alkylation | substitution of an alkyl group into an arene using a halogenoalkane and AlCl3 |
| Friedel–Crafts acylation | substitution of an acyl group, RCO–, into an arene using an acyl chloride and AlCl3, forming an aromatic ketone |
| directing effect | the influence of a group already on a benzene ring on the position at which a further substituent enters |
| free-radical substitution | substitution by a mechanism involving radicals, with initiation, propagation and termination steps; in arenes it occurs in an alkyl side chain in UV light |
Summary
- Benzene and methylbenzene react with strong electrophiles by electrophilic substitution: nitration (conc. HNO3/conc. H2SO4, 25–60 °C, NO2+), halogenation (X2 + AlX3, X+), Friedel–Crafts alkylation (CH3Cl + AlCl3, heat, CH3+) and acylation (CH3COCl + AlCl3, heat, CH3CO+).
- Each catalyst generates the electrophile and is regenerated when H+ is lost: H+ + HSO4− → H2SO4; H+ + AlX4− → AlX3 + HX.
- Mechanism: arrow from the π system to E+; intermediate with a horseshoe over five carbons and + inside; arrow from C–H into the ring; H+ released. Step 1 is slow and rate-determining.
- Substitution predominates because it restores the delocalised π system and its stabilisation; addition would destroy it.
- Hot alkaline KMnO4, then dilute acid, oxidises any alkyl side chain completely to –COOH. H2 with Pt or Ni and heat hydrogenates the ring to a cyclohexane.
- Halogen with AlX3 in the dark substitutes the ring (electrophilic); halogen in UV light substitutes the side chain (free radical).
- –NH2, –OH, –R direct to 2,4 (and 6) and activate the ring; –NO2, –COOH, –COR direct to 3 and deactivate it. The order of steps in a synthesis is chosen so the right group is present to direct each new one.
Examination checklist
- Can I give complete reagents and conditions for all six arene reactions and for side-chain halogenation?
- Can I write balanced equations for generating NO2+, Cl+, Br+, CH3+ and CH3CO+, and for regenerating each catalyst?
- Can I draw the mechanism with both curly arrows correctly placed, the correct intermediate, and H+ — including for an unfamiliar electrophile or ring?
- Can I explain why benzene undergoes substitution rather than addition?
- Can I predict the product of oxidising any alkylbenzene, and of hydrogenating any arene?
- Can I choose conditions for ring or side-chain halogenation and draw the distinct products of each?
- Can I state the directing effect of –NH2, –OH, –R, –NO2, –COOH and –COR, and use it to decide the order of steps?
- Can I explain why an alkyl group directs to the 2- and 4-positions in terms of carbocation stability?
Knowledge organiser
| idea | key facts | must-remember distinctions and common errors |
|---|---|---|
| Nitration | conc. HNO3 + conc. H2SO4, 25–60 °C; HNO3 + 2H2SO4 → NO2+ + H3O+ + 2HSO4− | both acids concentrated; > 60 °C gives dinitro |
| Halogenation (ring) | X2 + AlX3, rt, dry; X2 + AlX3 → X+ + AlX4− | no water; electrophile is X+, not X− |
| Friedel–Crafts | RCl or RCOCl + AlCl3, heat; R+ or RCO+ | name as alkylation or acylation; acylium attacks through C |
| Mechanism | π → E+; horseshoe + over 5 C; C–H → ring; H+ | + not on sp³ C; arrow from bond, not H |
| Substitution not addition | loss of H+ restores delocalisation (~150 kJ mol−1) | "benzene is stable" alone is not enough |
| Side-chain oxidation | hot alkaline KMnO4, then H+ → benzoic acid | whole chain; each alkyl group → COOH |
| Hydrogenation | H2, Pt/Ni, heat → cyclohexane ring | 3H2 per ring; side chain unchanged |
| Ring vs side chain | AlCl3, dark → ring (2,4); UV → side chain (radical) | equivalent CH3 groups give one product |
| Directing | –NH2, –OH, –R → 2,4; –NO2, –COOH, –COR → 3 | explain every group present; order steps accordingly |